Some possibilities...
1st: Particular about appearance. Neat appearance. An eye for detail. Noticing details on clothes. Perfectly groomed eyebrows. Noticing pores. Attention to nails and belly button lint. Worrying about appearance. Worrying about not looking perfect. Seeking to look perfect through plastic surgery. Schoolmarms. Plain Janes. Dressing appropriately for the occasion. A love of fine tailoring. Doing the "right" thing. A conscientious approach to life. A timid, shy, standoffish person. A humble, helpful, unselfish person. A critical, nitpicking, fault-finding person. A person who strives for physical perfection. A person who strives for perfection on the job. A perfect work performance. A perfect report card. A flawless attendance record. A person who is focused on everyday work and everyday routines. A person who does best when adhering to a routine. A person who is body-conscious. Perfecting the body through daily exercise. A person who is health-conscious. A person who is preoccupied with illness and health. A hypochondriac. Someone who carries around hand sanitizer and Airborne. Workaholics. Taking on the appearance of someone with a particular occupation. Looking like a (fill in the blank). Knowing how to adapt one's appearance to the situation. Adapting one's manner and approach to the situation at hand. An adaptable person. A cynical outlook. A skeptic. A pessimist. A worrywart. Worrying about job performance. Small problems are overwhelming. Overwhelmed by the details. Worrying about health. Worrying about physical appearance. Worrying about worrying too much. Meeting life with a specific skill set. An analytical approach. The ability to perceive flaws. A helpful approach. Crafting one's life. Liking small animals. Liking clean animals. Preferring cats to dogs. A practical approach to life. A practical approach to appearance. Consistently working to perfect every aspect of one's life. Consistently working to perfect one's appearance. Working on the body. Working on one's health. Treating life like a job to perform. Life is work. Liking to have something to do. Liking to be busy. A dutiful approach to life. Lack of spontaneity. Overly concerned with acting appropriately. Teacher's pet (not on purpose). Clear perception. Noticing the details. Perfecting the details. Wanting a perfect life. (Madonna, Tom Cruise, Kurt Cobain, Bruce Willis, Tom Hanks, Audrey Tautou, Emma Watson, Woody Allen, Tiger Woods, Walt Disney, Winston Churchill, Oscar Wilde, Hugh Hefner, Dolly Parton, Ernest Hemingway, and JRR Tolkein)